Arjun’s Concerns about the deterioration of the eternal Family-Dharm' — Shlok' 40-43 (continued 2)

चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागशः
"ChaaturVarnyam Maya Srishtam"  said so Bhagawaan Shri Krishn in BhagavadGita

It has become fashionable to invent different meanings

It has become fashionable to explain this Shlok from BhagavadGita in a different manner because that explanation gets readily accepted in today’s environment.

Today’s environment has been carefully cultivated over six generations. Christian Missionary Education System was established in 1835 spearheaded by Thomas Babington Macaulay. Simultaneously Ancient Hindu Education System was systematically uprooted from the land of the Hindus by the ChristianBritish administrative machinery Seed-2.

To uproot Hindu children from their roots and divert their inclination towards Christianity

Macaulay brought a battalion of Christian Missionaries to open Convents and Missionary Schools all over BhaaratVarsh. Next six generation of Hindus have remained under their spell. Those Christian Missionaries who controlled the ChristianEnglish Education System had one fundamental agenda: to uproot Hindu children from their roots and divert their inclination towards Christianity.

Their motto till today remains the same

Even now significantly large section of educational institutions in our country are run and/or controlled by Christian Converts and/or Funding from Christian sources abroad. Their motto till today remains the same: uproot Hindu children from their roots and divert their inclination towards Christianity.

Not finding satisfactory alternative in Christianity

Hindu children effectively uprooted from their Hindu religious and cultural roots - not finding satisfactory alternative in Christianity - attracted towards Marxism - have taken effective control of fabulously funded JNU and other Central Institutions like NCERT and ICHR.

This, in turn, has placed the remote control of a large section of other educational institutions in their hand. They design the textbooks and decide on their contents and these textbooks are then taught at premier institutions all over the country.  

This is how tomorrow’s adults are made out of today’s children

The process of brainwashing effectively begins at this point. Children are fed with lies about their heritage, about their ancestors, about their social systems, about their customs, about their religion, and practically about everything that matters with regard to building their future outlook towards their own society. This is how tomorrow’s adults are made out of today’s children. The future of Hindu BhaaratVarsh will be in hands of such brainwashed anti-Hindus.

Present Birth Theory

Among these ChristianEnglish educated the theory that has gained considerable popularity is the present birth theory. Proponents of this theory try to explain that Bhagawaan Shri Krishn referred to traits and deeds of "present birth", which would mean, expressed differently, occupation of the present birth.

Until Hindus keep believing in Bhagawaan Shri Krishn

They do not wish to challenge this statement of BhagavadGita "ChaaturVarnyam Maya Srishtam". They haven’t yet acquired that courage because large part of the Hindu population still has faith in Bhagawaan Shri Krishn. But they will not hesitate to challenge that statement once Hindu faith is substantially eroded in Bhagawaan Shri Krishn. And that process is gathering momentum.

But things are changing fast

Already Bhagawaan Shri Raam’s photos are being burned and the immortal epic Raamaayan is also receiving similar treatment. This is happening in small pockets of this large country but then efforts are on its way to give such movements extra push.

Already our Christianized Government has gone on record to state that Shri Raam never existed and Raam Setu at Raameshwaram has no historical basis.

University level books denounce Bhagawaan Shiv as drunkard and womanizer, so did the leading newspaper The Times of India, and some school textbooks show Bhagawaan Shri Krishn in very poor light.

Children who will learn such things at school level will tomorrow pass on the same kind of learning with added ugliness to their next generation.  

Returning to Present Birth Theory

This theory has gained considerable popularity as it gets ready acceptance and causes no heart burns. Effectively it has become the escape route for the intellectuals and the preachers alike. No one wants to stir the hornet’s nest when the going is easy.

The inspiration comes from

Those who invented this explanation were inspired either by personal interests and/or by influence of Christian Missionary education. As for Christianity, it subscribed to the theory of prior birth for humans until AD 543 when the Council of Constantinople banned it at the instance of Empress Theodora.

While the commoner’s understanding depends on...

A commoner’s understanding of this depends on various factors, among them are: personal interest, educational background, cultural background, media exposure, and also their individual progress towards spirituality.

Escape route for intellectuals and preachers alike

When people find it inconvenient to question the statement of Bhagawaan Shri Krishn, they prefer to explain it away in a different manner. They present an explanation: He did not mean it by birth, but He meant it by occupation. Such explanation can be cited with an example: "If a couple had three sons who became saadhu, leader and businessman then what will be their "Jaati"? They would be Braahman, Kshatriya and Vaishya according to their occupation irrespective of the "Jaati" of their birth".

And others find it easier to keep parroting it

This explanation has gained considerable ground over the period, and many keep parroting it, like it was done in the above case, in an article published on the editorial page of The Free Press Journal on 6 March 2004 by an individual who flashed his Ph.D. This approach is hypocritical, because here you tend to explain it away in a more socially acceptable way, looking at the direction in which wind blows today.

First let us look at these Unexplained Questions

Take your own case

Probably you think that the person in you is made of predominantly two factors -

Did you ask yourself a few simple questions?

Why is it that you were born only of those parents who gave you those genes?

Why were you not born of another set of parents who could have given you totally different hereditary factors?

Why were you born in that environment, which helped shape, you in a particular character?

Why were you not born in another set of environment that could have shaped you entirely into another kind of character?

Look at it from another angle

You and your brother both are born of same parents and also raised in the same environment -

Why then you both are different, and at times so very different that it almost looks like the opposites?

Ask yourself a couple more simple questions

"Who decides" these settings, as to "which parents" through whom you should be born, or into "which environment" you should be born, or "when" you should be born?

"Who regulates" these things, by making them happen, the way they do happen?

Would you want to call them "coincidences" just because your logical faculties cannot explain them? Can your logic reach there where your knowledge hasn’t reached yet?

Child that arrives on this Earth

चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागशः
ChaaturVarnyam Mayaa Srishtam Gun’Karm’Vibaagashah (ShrimadBhagavadGita Adhyaay 4 Shlok 13) would mean
"I have evolved the 4-Varn System based on Gun’Karm"
Where U in GUN is pronounced as in PUT, not as in SUN, and
N in GUN is pronounced with a Hard Tone and Fullness at the end.
For simplicity sake you may want to Understand GUN गुण as TRAIT and KARM कर्म as DEED.
Also remember KARM and KARM’YOG have different connotations.

Bhagawaan Shri Krishn spoke of birth-based classification not of work-based classification

Bhagawaan Shri Krishn spoke of birth-based classification depending on division of Gun and Karm.

Child that arrives on this planet Mother Earth

It cannot choose its "mother" and "father". It cannot choose its "surroundings" at the time of birth. It cannot choose "environment" that it would live-in during its early childhood

The family in which it takes birth

Depending on its ‘traits and deeds’ in its "prior incarnations", it takes birth through Braahman parents or Kshatriya parents or Vaishya parents or Shoodr parents. This does "not" happen by accident or by coincidence, as the present day rationalists would want us to believe. There is a "meticulous system" in place that monitors the whole process

Origin of the soul

Soul emerges from the Supreme Soul. At its origin, it has no character of its own

Physical birth

It descends on this earth encased in a body

Its own identity

Its ego अहंभाव gives it a distinct identity. Its thoughts and actions (deeds) are guided by this ego

Numerous births

It acquires various traits, in varying degree, in course of its long journey of numerous and successive births. It builds a reservoir of its Gun (traits) and Karm (deeds) through that process.

Physical death

Soul sheds its body at the time of departure from this earth. It does not take with it in physical form the traits it acquired and deeds it performed, during its stay on the earth

Successive birth

In its successive birth, it collects back those traits from the environment of this earth. During the process of birth and growing up, it regains those traits from its parents and environment.

Acquisition of Traits

Some traits it acquires back during the process of its birth - that include the genes it acquires from its earthly parents. Other traits it acquires back in the process of its growing up - that include the environment it receives in form of friends, teachers, surroundings, and etc.

Preset environment to grow up

Each new birth gives the new born a place in the society - with that it gets a preset environment to grow up. This place and environment is the result of its deeds through prior incarnations - these are not by its choice

Predetermined - not by Choice

It cannot choose its parents. It cannot choose its time of birth. It cannot choose its surroundings at the time of birth. It cannot choose its environment during its early childhood.

Complex mechanism automatically takes care of every detail at this particular stage

Process of birth itself takes care of positioning the soul in a certain situation

Prior Karm, not Free Will at this particular stage

All this is governed by soul’s prior (accumulated) Karm. At this particular stage Free Will has no role to play.

Free Will gets its due chance but at later stage

The turn for free will does come, but later. And that too, at different times in life of different individuals. One individual gets the opportunity to exercise free will early in life, whereas another gets much later in life, and neither of them can choose that particular moment in their respective lives.

The Journey of a Soul

The journey of a soul is a very long process. It passes through innumerable births until it qualifies itself for submerging into the Supreme soul.

Character building process

Through this long and arduous journey the soul’s ego acquires [1] many Gun गुण.

Traits influence Deeds

During each of these births सत्व गुण Satv’Gun, रजोगुण RajoGun and तमो गुण TamoGun arising from the प्रकृति Prakriti [2] induces the man to do many कर्म Karm.

Shaping of soul’s ego

Those Karm then make him the bearer of the results of such Karm. In this manner, takes shape the soul’s Ego अहंभाव.

But environment of earth is needed

However Satv’Gun/RajoGun/TamoGun can manifest themselves only in the environment of this world through a body.

Physical birth and choice of parents

When the time is ripe, the soul is then directed to such parents who, through their genes, and through the environment in which they live, would be able to give that body its required character.

Parents of parents

For parents to have acquired appropriate genes and environment, it would be necessary that their parents too had appropriate genes and environment.

Backward Integration of Genes

The same would apply to their parents, and then their parents, backward...
So, there has to be systematic process through which appropriate genes are passed from one generation to another.

Sophisticated system

And, for that one needs a comprehensive system in place: a regulated environment, and methodology functioning with high degree of precision.

[1] Think of it like character building through environmental influences
[2] Prakriti has been described as the material cause of the universe

Do not undermine the Capability of the Creator of this Universe

Any doubts?

Would you doubt that the Creator of this Universe lacks the ability to design and monitor such a profound system?

Look at your thumb

Think of Him when He created each human being with a distinct fingerprint.

Look into your eyes in a mirror

Think of Him when He created each human being with a distinct pupil in the eye.

Modern science knows so little

We do not even know how many more such distinctive characters He has built in the human system.

Yes, He can...

Would you ever doubt that such Creator cannot possibly monitor [3] the channeling of birth for each and every human being, that is, which parents they should be born of, in which environment each individual must be born into, and what time and place each individual should take its first breath on this earth?

Yes, He can monitor each and every such phenomenon howsoever complex it may sound.

Without a beginning and without an end

It is He who has created this Universe, which has no known beginning and end to the mankind.

Modern science does not even know enough of our own Solar system, leave aside how many more Solar systems and how many more Galaxies exist in this whole Universe.

Just because our own human ability is so very limited

We should not doubt the ability of the Creator of this Universe, just because our own human ability is so very limited.

He does have the capability of monitoring an extraordinarily complex system of human birth, which is even beyond imagination of man and woman raised under modern education system with Christian roots.

[3] Here I am not getting into the issue of Nir’Gun character of Ishwar but I would like you to know that there is no inherent contradiction in the two aspects. I would want to elaborate on those things in another work ~ this is simply not the right place (b) I would want to add only this much here that monitoring does not entail that He must personally supervise each and every function though He is capable of doing that as well ~ it is sufficient for Him to establish a system which monitors the whole phenomenon howsoever complex it may be (c) In short, what you need to understand is that this Creation works like a clockwork and is governed by a highly sophisticated mathematical module that is even beyond human comprehension through study of books. You need to connect yourself to Higher Order and it is He who may decide to give you (or not) the necessary understanding, and also, only to that extent that He feels you are ready to grasp (d) Every aspect of this Creation is interrelated and interdependent connected through an invisible chain of mathematical modules.

Timing the event of birth

We have stated earlier that when the time is ripe, the soul is then directed to such parents who, through their genes, and through the environment in which they live, would be able to give that body its required character.

Now we will look at the issue of timing the event of birth. Here we need to go into a deep and complex mechanism that works like clockwork with a precision unknown to human mind.

The Moment of its First Contact with the Environment of this Earth

By Time here we refer to soul’s breathing its first breath on this earth. That is, the moment of its first contact with the environment of this earth, out of the protection of the mother’s womb.

With such extraordinary finesse and precision this is designed by the Creator that no human super-computer would come anywhere near, even at miles distance from it.

Before proceeding a few basics

Before proceeding we need to understand few other basics; then only the examples that will be presented hereafter, will make some sense.

I am describing these to a Commoner and in a language that he will understand

While describing we are not seeking precision of expression but we seek simplicity of expression so that complex phenomenon, if not understood, at least does not fail to create some intelligible impression.

Understanding the Sky

We see the sky above us. We also see the stars and planets above us in the sky. We cannot recognize them but we have heard or read that astronomers can do so.

If astronomers can do that then there is some scientific basis to it for, at least, astronomy is recognized as a science.

Definitive methodology in place

So the first thing we take for granted is that there is a definitive methodology in place to recognize various positions in the sky, which to us ordinary people could be baffling.

Scientifically identifiable divisions of the Sky

So we first come to this acceptance that there are specific divisions of the sky that are astronomically identifiable by the position of Fixed Stars.

Understanding a "Star in the Sky", as you would understand a "House in the City"

Now these are fixed stars, they are not mobile; they do not change their position in the sky as planets do.

Therefore, a particular segment of the sky can be easily identified by the position of that particular star.

That position, for simplicity sake, is like the position of our house, which does not move away from its original location when we return home at the end of the day; we find our house situated at the same place and our family inside it.

As a house has a fixed address in the city, similarly a star has a fixed address in the sky. Therefore, we are not speaking of imaginary segments of the unlimited sky, but of clearly identifiable places in this limitless sky.

Nakshatr and Star are not the same

We will find reference to Nakshatr in what will follow hereafter, and therefore it is necessary to clarify that Nakshatr is not Sanskrit equivalent of star.

A Nakshatr may comprise of more than one fixed star.

Understanding a "Raashi in the Sky" as you would understand a "Zone in the City"

As a city can be divided into several zones similarly the sky is also divided into several zones for identification purposes. The positions of these zones do not change. Let us call them Raashi instead of zones for our purposes.

Now it is necessary to understand here that within each zone there can be many stars. In other words, within each Raashi there can be more than one Nakshatr. Think of it something like many houses inside a zone within a city.

In a city we have each zone with well-defined parameters; similarly, in the sky each Raashi has its well-defined ambit.

In the city each block comprising couple of buildings has a predefined area and that is available in the municipal records; similarly, in the sky each Nakshatr has predefined area and that is available in astronomical records. For purposes of identification, each Nakshatr has been given a name, as we have given names to fixed stars and planets. It is somewhat like giving a name to a person or a house.

The addresses of these Nakshatrs are mentioned in terms of degrees in the sky. We will be using Sanskrit names of Nakshatrs.

It is also important to note that all references to the time of birth are in relation to moon, not to sun. There will be references to moon’s position in the sky and therefore, it may be relevant to recapitulate that moon is mobile, changes its position in the sky and therefore, at one day it may be seen in one Nakshatr and the next day it may have moved to the next Nakshatr.

Through many births a soul acquires a complex character of conflicting traits

Let us now look at the case of a Kshatriya. In its purest form, a Kshatriya may be Kshatriya by birth [born in Kshatriya family], Kshatriya by physical qualities, Kshatriya by mental makeup; thus Kshatriya in totality. But with many births, it does not retain this purity. In every birth, it absorbs different Gun (traits) from the environment of this earth. These Gun(s) then reflect through its Karm (deeds). Over many births, it builds up a reservoir of conflicting (good and bad) Gun and Karm. This makes its composite character a complex one. Thus, it does not remain in its purest form, as described above. This entitles it for different levels of birth during different incarnations. For instance, if its (soul’s) Karm had been more of Saatvic nature, then it would graduate towards an environment, which would ensure its further growth towards spiritual quests. In a situation like that, it may have many attributes of Kshatriya, but mental makeup of a Braahman. We know of king-rishis like Janak and VishwaaMitr. We will describe what Saatvic is in a subsequent work. Similarly, it may have many attributes of Kshatriya, but the mental makeup of a Vaishya, or a Shoodr, or even a butcher.

Mechanism that would govern the Timing of Birth for each Soul

Now we discuss, in a very broad manner, the mechanism that governs timing of birth, for such souls. In these discussions, we are not seeking precision, instead we are attempting at providing an indication, so that readers have a rough idea.

I am not here to teach you the highly developed ancient science of astrology [4]. My objective is to remove the dread of ignorance that grips your psyche. It is just an opportunity to get a feel of the highly complex mechanism described in simple language. No more, no less. And that too, only if you care to.

In all following examples here, the timing of birth essentially refers to the moment when a soul breathes its first breath on this earth encased in a human body.

And when we talk about Raashi or Nakshatr and degrees we are essentially referring to moon’s position (not sun’s position) in "that address of the sky" at the time of birth.

Broad indications of Timing of Birth of a Kshatriya born with Conflicting Traits

A Kshatriya born with Braahman mental makeup would be born under PoorvPhaalguni Nakshatr between 13° 21’ and 26° 40’ in Sinh Raashi or PoorvAashaarh Nakshatr between 13° 21’ and 26° 40’ in Dhanu Raashi. A Kshatriya with Braahman mental makeup will tend to function better in providing the nation a just and fair administration with a thrust towards education and moral values, with support towards religion, and with prudent strategic planning.

A Kshatriya born with Kshatriya mental makeup would be born under UttarPhaalguni Nakshatr between 26° 41’ and 30° in Sinh Raashi or UttarAashaarh Nakshatr between 26° 41’ and 30° in Dhanu Raashi. A Kshatriya with Kshatriya mental makeup will tend to function better in providing the nation a safe environment for its subjects, who may live in a secured state, and a powerful state towards which enemies may not make advances.

A Kshatriya born with Shoodr mental makeup would be born under Magha Nakshatr between 0° and 13° 20’ in Sinh Raashi. A Kshatriya with Shoodr mental makeup will tend to function better in the army as a soldier, serving well, fighting for the nation, giving his life when necessary.

A Kshatriya born with Servant mental makeup would be born under Chitra Nakshatr between 0° and 6° 40’ in Tula Raashi. A Kshatriya with Servant mental makeup will tend to function better in the army cooking food for the soldiers, doing their laundry, etc.

A Kshatriya born with Butcher mental makeup would be born under Swaati Nakshatr between 6° 41’ and 20° in Tula Raashi or under Mool Nakshatr between 0° and 13° 20’ in Dhanu Raashi. A Kshatriya with Butcher mental makeup will tend to function better in an army that would tend to destroy other civilizations, their culture, their universities, etc.

A Kshatriya born with Mlechchh mental makeup would be born under Vishaakha Nakshatr between 20° 1’ and 30° in Tula Raashi. Mlechchh refers to a misfit amongst defined categories.

These are some broad over-simplified examples of conflicting traits that such a Kshatriya born would display in its earthly character.

Such mixed Varn souls would require parents of mixed Varn to give them appropriate genes

A soul passing through the passage of innumerable births, having acquired complex character of its own, would naturally require parents of mixed Varn, who would be able to give appropriate genes to the body of such child. So, all this is interrelated, inter-dependent, one influencing the other, and part of a complex cyclic process that can be given full effect to, through the course of numerous births. These are by no means exhaustive but only illustrative of a highly complex phenomenon of unimaginable magnitude that works with such a fine mathematical precision that could be beyond human comprehension. The Creator who can create innumerable life forms, and within that while looking at just one life form, which is of humans, we find each product (each human), as unique in itself.

The Free Will was NOT given to us for "meddling" with the System of Creation

It is we humans that meddle with the system of creation. The Creator has given us free will so that we can navigate ourselves through the course of our life towards our final destination - Journey to the Supreme Soul. But we choose to use it to interfere with the fundamental structure and thereby, bid good-bye to the base simplicity in the system, and let it complicate itself by mathematical principle of permutations and combinations. Complexities thus grow to enormous levels, and in the process we destroy the system through ages that follow; and as with time everything must decay, so does the base structure.

Nevertheless the System takes into account all your "meddling" and deals with them effectively

All your meddling get captured and recorded into the database of which no human created comparison is possible. And all those variations are given due effect to when the system designs a by-product. Think of the Nature’s process or Ishwar’s Creation phenomenon as the system. Think of the new born character as the by-product. Think of all the meddling as Karm of prior births. How the timing and place of birth determination gives all these variables their due effect is something that can be explained further by similar examples as given earlier by expanding that horizon. But then, it will go beyond the scope of this work and therefore, let us wait for another work which may attempt to provide you with some insight into the mechanism. However, I have nothing to tell them for whom this Creation process is a random affair.

[4] "It is not a question of belief; the scientific attitude one should take on any subject is whether it is true. The law of gravitation worked as efficiently before Newton, as after him. The cosmos would be fairly chaotic if its laws could not operate without the sanction of human belief ... Astrology is too vast, both mathematically and philosophically, to be rightly grasped except by men of profound understanding. If ignoramuses misread the heavens, and see there a scrawl instead of a script, that is to be expected in this imperfect world. One should not dismiss the wisdom of the wise. All parts of creation are linked together and interchange their influences. The balanced rhythm of the universe is rooted in reciprocity ... Astrology is the study of man’s response to planetary stimuli. The stars ... offer a lawful channel for the outward operation of cause-effect equilibriums that each man has set into motion in the past. A child is born on that day and at that hour when the celestial rays are in mathematical harmony with his individual Karm" Swami Yukteshwar Giri quoted by Paramahansa Yogananda in his Autobiography of a Yogi, pp.161-162
The story of Sir Isaac Newton may interest some. I read it in one of the books written by Dr. B V Raman sometime in the year 2000. As I have dozens of his books, I find myself short of time to locate, in which book, on which page, I had read this, and therefore, I am skipping here the precise reference. Dr. B V Raman narrated the following incidence about Newton’s life. However, the interpretation that I present afterwards is mine.
Sir Isaac Newton’s personal library was known for its collection on astrology. One day Halley asked him: of all, ‘you’ believe in ‘these’ things? Newton aptly replied: I have studied them, but you have not!
Read between the lines it would mean: do not distrust what you know nothing about! So, the ignorance does not make something unscientific. Halley perceived it as unscientific for he was ignorant of it. Today vast majority of scientists fall in this category but their ballooned ego would not let them admit this.
Newton, on the other hand, was a true scientist in this respect, who would not reject anything on preconceived notion until proven otherwise. Unfortunately, most who carry the university label of scientist today are not scientifically inclined ‘even to begin to understand’ this finer point. That is why they are not Newton.
Newton, Sir Isaac (1642-1727), English mathematician and physicist, considered the greatest single influence on theoretical physics until Einstein. Oxford Dictionary, p.1249
This preamble was not directed to belittle modern scientists. It was to put the skeptics in place, though the so-called modern scientists too need a rebuke. I, for one, do not have much respect for them because they do not have adequate respect for Hindu science. The day they will start giving Hindu science adequate respect, I shall start respecting them. Respect is always mutual, not one sided.
Who is a true scientist? Not necessarily one who holds University recognition as a scientist is truly a scientist, though today these are the people who are understood to be the scientists of the modern times.
A true scientist is one who has the scientific spirit, one who has a scientific bent of mind, one who does not dismiss as ‘unscientific’ something that he or she has not put to rigorous and consistent testing, patiently, after taking due pains to research, honestly, into all facets of available knowledge and evidence.
But today’s most so-called scientists who carry the badge of a scientist do ‘not’ seem to reflect this quality and this tendency, in their conduct, when it comes to the knowledge of the Ancients.

Arjun’s Concerns about rise of Varn’Sankars

Shlok 40-43: Arjun continues, "When the family decays, the eternal FamilyDharm deteriorates, and with that, the entire family comes under influence of Adharm. When Adharm persists, and it engulfs the entire family, then women in the family take to the path of immorality. When women take that course, they give birth to children of mixed-Varn. This process leads to rise of men of mixed-Varn in the family, and thus, the family goes to the dogs. With that certain rituals related to the ancestors are ignored, and the process leads to the decay of ancestral lineage. With this mixed-Varn, FamilyDharm and the race both deteriorate to its end."

The issue of Varn’Sankars is mostly avoided by commentators. Reason is simple—it has become a very touchy issue these days. Not that the issue itself is so sensitive—it has been made unduly sensitive issue by hyper publicity using every possible platform (education, media, politics, etc) ever since Christian missionary led English education system gained its foothold. Those who believe that discretion is better of valor they prefer to use discretion and avoid commenting on the issue. To me neither discretion nor valor is relevant—truth is. Therefore, I shall do some plain talking.

Varn’Sankar means hybrid—product of two Varn(s). And Arjun’s concern was that it would destroy the society of humans. How very true in today’s context! Look at the process of deterioration in Hindu society keeping in mind history of Hindu society that I have so far presented.
Since when Varn’Sankars started becoming plentiful? Wasn’t it from the time of arrival of the barbarians? They had no family values. Not only Aurangzeb who had sex with his own daughter but even today you get to read in newspapers of father-in-law having sex with daughter-in-law or father having sex with daughter. Aren’t these news items predominantly from those people who follow the same religion as did Aurangzeb? When they could do this to their own kin what do you think they would have done to the Hindu women? So, that was the time since when number of Varn’Sankars began to rise on this pious land of BhaaratVarsh. The process went on for centuries to have produced enough of Varn’Sankars.

Next lot was of popes’ men with legacy from the Popes who had sex with their daughter/produced innumerable bastards, and bishops who had sex with kids who came to church—not handful but numerous cases—read through my published works on Christianity for documented evidence with references. They too created large number of Varn’Sankars—one who proudly called themselves Anglo-Indians since they thought of themselves to be the progeny of the superior race—superior in barbarism and cunningness—read Voltaire and others in Seed-2—and the other category who preferred to remain unnamed due to Lajja (sense of shame though it was not their doing but then they were forced by the so-called superior race).

Anyhow, this period of many centuries saw phenomenal growth in the number of Varn’Sankars. All bloodlines got messed up thoroughly. But the greater part of the harm came through the Christian missionary led English education system which irreversibly altered the thought process of Hindu children that there was nothing wrong in this mix-up. Net result was the inevitable—Hindus themselves began to oppose the tradition and began to demand mixed marriages. To top it came the cinema which began to inject the love bug so profusely among the youth that they began to get into love fever but at the same time they had to face opposition from both families. This is where Arya Samaj came to their rescue who would readily help the two love birds marry, and thus raise the number of their followers—after all they too believed that idolater Hindus were fools and Hindu gods/goddesses were false gods. Any how the number of Varn’Sankars steadily grew in the society and it put in tatters the very fabric of Hindu society.

The Touchstone Test*

Now the question is whether it is good or bad for a human society? I see no point wasting time debating on theory. Let us compare results—if the results are good, it is good—if the results are bad, it is bad. Period. Simple, isn’t it?

I need not repeat the results of Varn system in Hindu society—you have already seen (Seed-2) what an enviable class of people it produced for millenniums—it represented true humanity—a kind of human society unheard of in the annals of human history in any other part of the world. Thus, there remains absolutely no scope for doubt that Varn System has been very good for the humanity in every respect.

Now let us see whether enormous spread of Varn’Sankars has been good for the nation or not. Let us begin from the time ChristianBritish left and Nehru dynasty began. Let us examine the antecedents of Nehru clan. Shri R V Bhasin, Advocate Supreme Court, has published two small documents "Mrs. Sonia Gandhi & The Nehru/Gandhi Dynasty" and "A Tale of Two Lals—Motilal & Jawahar Lal" (ISBN 81-67405-04-X published 11 Oct 2005). I am analyzing here some of the information picked up from those publications—

Nawab Khan was a Muslim and his wife was a Muslim by conversion and Parsi by birth. Children born of a Muslim man and a Parsi woman will be Varn’Sankar. Children born of a Muslim man and a Muslim woman will be a Muslim. Their son Feroze Khan was a Varn’Sankar and a Muslim because his mother was Parsi by birth and Muslim by conversion. Feroze Khan was buried according Muslim rites in Allahabad after death.

Feroze Khan was married to Mainuna Begum in 1941 in a mosque at London. To meet legal requirements, notice of this marriage was published in major local newspapers in the name of Feroze Khan. Mainuna Begum’s name before conversion to Islam was Indira Gandhi.

Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi advised Jawaharlal Nehru to get Feroze Khan’s name changed to Feroze Gandhi. His excuse was that Feroze Khan’s mother maiden name was Gandhi. Allahabad’s famous lawyer and Motilal’s good friend Sir Sapru filed an affidavit in the court and got the name changed.

After return to BhaaratVarsh, in presence of media, the whole marriage was repeated with Hindu rites and the photographs were put up at Anand Bhawan at Allahabad. This was to complete the process of conspiracy that began with change of name by affidavit and conspiracy of silence was maintained to make the untruth look like truth to the Hindus of BhaaratVarsh. A marriage of two Muslims—one by birth (Feroze) and the other by conversion (Indira)—performed in accordance with Vedic rites was invalid and therefore, whole drama in full glare of media was an act of deception towards the Hindus.

No information is available if and when Indira became a Hindu again by renouncing Islam. If Indira continued to remain a Muslim then her son Rajiv would be Muslim by birth because Feroze had remained a Muslim till death and name change was done, against his will, only to satisfy the demand (protect the political aspirations) of Jawaharlal Nehru and Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi. If Mainuna Begum renounced Islam and reconverted herself to Hinduism then Rajiv would be a Varn’Sankar.

Feroze Khan (Gandhi) and Mainuna Begum (Indira) separated (not divorced) for reasons unclear after Rajiv’s birth.

Second son Sanjiv was arrested in England for stealing a car and his passport was confiscated. Krishn Menon was High Commissioner in London at that time. He got Sanjiv a new passport under changed name Sanjay.

Sanjay was married to Menaka (name changed to Maneka) under peculiar circumstances at the house of Muhammad Yunus of New Delhi, supposedly the biological father of Sanjay.

When Sanjay died in plane crash the person who wept most was Muhammad Yunus. His book "Persons, Passions and Politics" describes the circumcision of child Sanjay according to Muslim rites.

When Indira was informed of Sanjay’s plane crash the first two questions she asked: (1) what happened to the bunch of keys he carried and (2) what happened to wrist watch he was wearing. Interesting isn’t it?

At the time of marriage, Rajiv converted himself to Christianity and adopted a new name Roberto. His daughter was named as Bianca and son’s name is Raul. They are citizen of Italy. Priyanka and Rahul are for consumption of Hindu voters. Bianca (Priyanka) is married to a Christian and the first thing she did after she was discharged from the hospital after her delivery was to go to Bandra Church to seek blessings. Raul (Rahul) is said to be hooked to a Christian girl.

After taking over the office of the Prime Minister, at a media gathering, Rajiv had himself said: I am not a Hindu. At this New York Times, Los Angles Times and Washington Post praised him profusely. But when Rajiv died his cremation was done according to Vedic rites. Why? To fool Hindu masses.

It is true that Rajiv studied at Cambridge University in England but it is equally true that during his three years stay at Cambridge he did not pass a single examination and returned without any certificate.

As for Sonia, she was working as an ‘au pair’ [5] girl and was trying to learn English at a ‘fly by night’ language school named Cambridge (not Cambridge University).

Motilal was not a barrister or lawyer but a Mukhtiar (helper of a lawyer) and he worked for famous lawyer Mubarak Ali who fought the case on behalf of Queen of Itawa and won the case at London’s Privi Council. As a reward she gave Mubarak Ali and Motilal the Jaagir of Amethi.

And Jawaharlal was a failure as a lawyer much the same as Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi was a failure as a Barrister but we have been taught otherwise. What was the need to hide the truth and propagate the untruth as truth?

Conclusion

Ever since independence the nation is being ruled by the Varn’Sankars. So, they select their types in the ministries and for significant positions elsewhere. The result is what we see around us today—I need not expand on it. I hope you understand what I am trying to say—the current state of affairs of our nation is due to excessive indulgence of Varn’Sankars in matters of governing the nation—that is my contention. The results speak for themselves—I do not have to prove it.

Arjun’s fear was appropriate but untimely

Islam and Christianity, and their abusive effect on Hindu Society between 7th and 21st century, has brought Hindu society now to a state, which Arjun had then feared.

Only Arjun’s fear was untimely because he feared this as the likely outcome of the war that he was about to face and therefore, wanted to desert the battlefield.

Bhagawaan Shri Krishn knew better and He asked Arjun to rise to the occasion and fight the battle on hand because that battle was meant to reestablish dharm, not to destroy FamilyDharm.

It was proved to be correct, for dharm was indeed reestablished following the battle of MahaaBhaarat, and we see so much of evidence through the accounts of foreign visitors as reproduced above. Those accounts are dated 404 BC onwards. Similar conditions must have prevailed after MahaaBhaarat until this time, because suddenly such strong social fabric could not have developed overnight. The structure must have evolved from the time battle of MahaaBhaarat ended and dharm was reestablished.

But today we see so much deterioration in FamilyDharm related issues, primarily as a result of Christianity effect on Hindu society, injected through Macaulayite Christian_English education system over past 170 years that effectively destroyed the structure that prevailed for 5,000 years after the battle of MahaaBhaarat. Such is the venomous impact of a system that we foolishly have become proud of!

I see no reason to be defensive

On a worldwide scale, if we look at the social structures evolved by Christian societies, Marxist societies and so-called Secular societies, we see them disintegrating already. The base unit ‘family’ is fast eroding the social fabric of modern society and we can look at the number of years they have withstood the test of time.

The test of time is the best test, it tells us what works in practice. It has worked for Hindu society; it has not worked for Christian societies, Marxist societies, and Secular societies long enough to stand the test of time.

And therefore, I see no reason to be defensive about Hindu system of social structure; those who abuse it looking at today’s situation, deliberately shut their eyes towards the fact that this very deterioration is the effect of its long association with Islamic, Christian, Marxist and Secular societies.

Instead of looking at the cause and effect relationship, these Hindu hater Indian-Englishmen, Christianized_Hindus and fake Secularists point fingers at the ancient system, which saved Hindu society from being obliterated by Islamic and Christian imperialism.

Arjun’s concern with regard to decay of ancestral lineage

Let us now return to Arjun’s other concern. He had been worried when he said, "With that certain rituals related to the ancestors are ignored, and the process leads to the decay of ancestral lineage".

Here we need to realize that the logic behind such rituals have been lost into antiquity with destruction of Hindu educational literature over a period of thousand years of Islamic invasions, followed by total withdrawal of governmental support towards Hindu education system in accordance with Macaulay’s plan, cemented by total disrespect towards Hindu education system impressed on Hindu minds through English-Christian schooling system in BhaaratVarsh over past one hundred and seventy years.

The life of a soul does not end with the life of a physical body. The soul has to go on and go on for ages from one body to another until it elevates itself sufficiently to submerge within the Supreme Soul. The soul has its habitation elsewhere during those intervals when it does not assume the outer clothing of a physical body and during this period of habitat there are things that become necessary. Now the rituals tend to fulfill some of its needs that we may not understand well today, thanks to Islamic and Christian imperialism but as Hindu awareness grows, which has now begun, the knowledge that has gone underground will start resurfacing gradually as the due respect would be shown to it. So it is for us to now show that desire to learn more of our heritage and then only we will be able to get it back.

Arjun’s concern was untimely for then but it is very much timely for today

Arjun had been worried when he said, "With this mixed-Varn FamilyDharm and the race both deteriorate to its end".

We see that very much in evidence today, because that is precisely what has happened to Hindu society with 170 years of Macaulayite Christian_English education system and influence of Communist-Marxist thought process.

*The Touch Stone Test - this topic was added to the enlarged 2008 edition published under title Seed 3
 [5] au pair = a young person, usually a woman, who lives with a family in a foreign country in order to learn the language. An au pair helps in the house and takes care of children and receives a small wage - Oxford Dictionary ISBN 019-431-5851

BhagavadGita — Adhyaay' 1 — Arjun'Vishaad'Yog' — Shlok' 1
Participants in the Battle of Dharm' and Adharm' — Shlok' 2-20
Arjun’s Dilemma — Shlok' 21-39
Arjun’s Concerns about the deterioration of the eternal Family-Dharm' — Shlok' 40-43
Arjun’s Concerns about the deterioration of the eternal Family-Dharm' — Shlok' 40-43 (continued)
Arjun’s Concerns about the deterioration of the eternal Family-Dharm' — Shlok' 40-43 (continued 2)
Arjun gives up and resigns, so has Hindu given up — Shlok' 44-47